Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Risotto Stuffed Mushrooms
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
Broccoli Rabe Sausage Hero
The Goodfella Hero
About
The Original Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza
The Original Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza is a culinary gem located at 4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY. This vibrant establishment is renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine, particularly its exquisite coal-fired pizzas. With an inviting atmosphere and a commitment to flavor, it has quickly become a community staple.
- Location and Atmosphere: Nestled in Staten Island, Goodfella’s boasts a warm, friendly ambiance. The decor captures the essence of Italy, making every visit feel special. Free Wi-Fi, a full bar, and outdoor seating options enhance the relaxed vibe, perfect for a casual lunch or dinner.
- Menu Highlights: Their pizza is the undeniable star here. Customers rave about the Quattro Formaggi—a delightful blend of cheeses that dances on the palate—and the roasted vegetable pizza, praised for its fresh flavors. The famous vodka pie stands out as an irresistible option too!
- Exceptional Service: The staff at Goodfella’s is known for their welcoming demeanor. Guests have expressed appreciation for the attentive service, which includes thoughtful food suggestions to elevate your dining experience.
- Community Favorite: Whether you're catching a game with friends or enjoying a family meal, The Original Goodfella’s is versatile enough to cater to all occasions. Regular customers describe it as one of the best pizza spots on Staten Island, making it a must-visit.
- Dining Options: Whether dining in or taking out, the delicious offerings remain consistently high quality. The restaurant accommodates reservations, and you can enjoy the benefits of delivery or catering for larger gatherings.
In summary, The Original Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza is more than just a restaurant; it's a cultural experience that melds mouthwatering food with a welcoming community spirit. From the friendly service to the tantalizing menu items, every visit promises to be a delightful escape into the world of Italian cuisine. Don’t forget to try their desserts, as they are equally tempting and round off your meal wonderfully!
For inquiries, you can reach them at (718) 987-2422.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ WOW! THIS PIZZA WAS WORTH THE TRIP FROM NJ! We will definitely come again and again! It's the best coal fired pizza we ever had! The pizza dough itself was DELICIOUS! They also start you with most delicious bread too! We had the Quattro formaggi and roasted vegetable pizza both were FANTASTIC! My personal favorite was the Quattro formaggi! The sauce was so delicious in that pie and so was the cheese! The roasted vegetable was AMAZING too! I highly recommend Goodfella's in Staten Island! ”
“ Great place to me up with family and friends or catch a game. Pizza is very creative with many types to choose from. Whether you want a pie at home or to go out, either way is a win win. ”
“ One of the best Pizza's on Staten Island, this is a community staple. Their famous vodka pie never disappoints and this new location has a very fresh atmosphere and very beautiful inside. ”
“ Upon entering we were greeted and seated. The manager the waitress were very pleasant and very nice. The ambiance was very nice it was in the last he was peaceful. The food was excellent it was delicious honestly I had a great time. I would definitely come back again highly recommend this place just maybe next time I wouldn't bring the girl came with me. Maybe trying to find a girl that appreciates going out to a nice place. But I guess I'm getting into my personal stuff sorry about that. Highly recommend. ”
“ This place has wonderful pizza. Very tasteful and fresh. The waiters were very nice and made food suggestions that we tried. The salads were tasty and we had so much that we took home food. The restaurant had lovely decor and you felt that you were eating n Italy. Do not forget ordering dessert. There were several choices and they were tasty. ”
“ Our family has members with food allergies, and Goodfellas has been a phenomenal revelation. Their whole staff from the kitchen to the front of the house are all trained in handling allergies and knowing what questions to ask. The fried calamari are breaded so lightly but have an immense crispness and crunch to them. Every pizza we've had has been amazing as well. The crust has a near perfect chew to it with a firmer edge that holds up to everything piled on top. It's casual and can get a little loud when it's crowded, but it definitely feels like a great neighborhood pizza joint that slings up fantastic pies. There's a bar area in the front full of taps and some TVs, but we've never sat up there. We've always been in the brighter main dining room. ”
“ Unbelievably good, thank you Dana We're never disappointed Even the drinks are amazing Can't wait to see you all again Thanks so much ”
“ Pretty good pizza. Ubereats was doing a BOGO for some. I got the Old World Style, Smoking Goodfella, and the White Clam Pie, all individual size. Pretty decent size, larger than I thought they were gonna be. I was excited for the White Clam but it was just ok. Good amount of sand I bit into but I understand the "fresh clams". The Old World Style was pretty good, my favorite of the three, very good tomato flavor, cheesy, and soft. The Smoking Goodfella was also good. The Buffalo Chicken wings were really good, just wish it came with ranch. ”
“ Very good pizza! I ordered thru ubereats and noted to have the boxes sealed with tape and they did exactly that which is a plus. since I've had prior experiences ordering from these apps, where food was not sealed and it was tampered with. All companies should seal there food. We got the vodka and the old world both were personal sizes so it's 4 slices but big slices. I'm not really used to vodka pizza have peas and prosciutto but if you like that you'll probably like this. The old world was good, lots of tomato sauce and the dough was nice not too thin and had a great chewy texture to it which I like! Will definitely try there other items. ”
“ Went on a Sunday afternoon for a beer and some pizza. The place is decorated very nicely with dark wood and nice lighting. We sat at the bar with a friendly bartender. Wifey had red wine and I chose Sam Summer out of a choice of about 20 tap beers. We ordered the vodka pie which was delicious! It was topped by peas, procciutto and mushrooms that were cooked to perfection. A nice crust rounded off an excellent pizza experience. The nice service made it a pleasant afternoon ”
